There’s a popular refrain that goes like this: “Measles was declared eradicated in the United States in 2000, but it has recently made a comeback because of declining vaccination rates.”
Now, just how do we know that measles was eradicated in 2000? Well, the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) says so, of course. Here’s exactly what the CDC says on its website,1 in response to the question, “Has measles been eliminated from the United States?”:
Yes. In 2000, the United States declared that measles was eliminated from this country. The United States was able to eliminate measles because it has a highly effective measles vaccine, a strong vaccination program that achieves high vaccine coverage in children and a strong public health system for detecting and responding to measles cases and outbreaks.
But there’s a little problem with this response. Read the question carefully again, and then read the answer… carefully. The CDC does not actually confirm that measles was eradicated in the US. It says that the US “declared” that measles was eliminated. It’s a nice lead-in to what amounts to a clever attempt at deception to make the public believe that the disease was essentially wiped out in 2000.
Anyone can declare victory. Hey, the US government declared victory in Vietnam. Doesn’t mean it was true. Kind of reminds me of the Seinfeld car reservation scene2 in which Jerry is told by the lady attendant that they don’t have anymore mid-size vehicles. Goes like this…
Jerry: I don’t understand. Do you have my reservation?
Rental Car Agent: We have your reservation, we just ran out of cars.
Jerry: But the reservation keeps the car here. That’s why you have the reservation.
Rental Car Agent: I think I know why we have reservations.
Jerry: I don’t think you do. You see, you know how to take the reservation, you just don’t know how to hold the reservation. And that’s really the most important part of the reservation: the holding. Anybody can just take them.
The CDC can declare measles was eliminated. You see, it knows how to declare the elimination, it just don’t know how to achieve the elimination. And that’s really the most important part of the elimination: the achieving. Anybody can just declare.
There was a total of 86 reported cases of measles in the US in 2000.3 There were outbreaks before 2000, and there have been outbreaks every year since. Measles has never been eliminated or eradicated in the US. But the impression you might get from the CDC is that it was, and that someone came along and messed up everything.
So now when you read articles that contain the phrases, “since measles was eradicated in 2000″ or “since we eliminated measles in 2000,” think about the Seinfeld episode, and smile.
References:
1 Centers for Disease Control. Frequently Asked Questions about Measles in the U.S. Centers for Disease Control.
2 From the Episode: The Alternate Side, Season 3, Episode 11. Seinfeld—The Car Reservation. YouTube.
3 Centers for Disease Control. Measles—United States, 2000 MMWR Weekly Feb. 15, 2002/51(06);120-3
2 Responses
I recall reading something similar about how USA never really eliminated the measles feom our country; we just had one period where it was not reported, but it had occurred each year!
Some people and media are so blind to deception!!
Nearly every news story one reads about measles these days claims that measles was “declared eliminated in 2000” by the CDC. Do you even know what that means? It’s not the definition most people would adhere to in common English usage, meaning removal or ridding.
“Elimination of disease: Reduction to zero of the incidence of a specified disease in a defined geographical area as a result of deliberate efforts; continued intervention measures are required. Example: neonatal tetanus.
Elimination of infections: Reduction to zero of the incidence of infection caused by a specific agent in a defined geographical area as a result of deliberate efforts; continued measures to prevent re-establishment of transmission are required. Example: measles, poliomyelitis.”
https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/su48a7.htm
Even with that specialized definition of “elimination”, measles never was eliminated. There were 86 cases in 2000, and there have been cases every single year since.
“During 2000, a total of 86 confirmed measles cases were reported… Of the 86 cases reported, 26 were imported from outside the United States, and 19 cases were epidemiologically linked to imported cases. Nine additional cases had virologic evidence of importation (i.e., genotypic analysis of measles viruses indicated no evidence of an endemic strain). The remaining 32 cases were classified as unknown source cases because no link to importation was detected.”
https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm4953a1.htm
The CDC asserts that if these cases originated in another part of the world and were brought here by travellers, they don’t count. So, even though there were 86 cases that year, and 32 of those cases came from an unknown source, the CDC “declared” measles eliminated. It never actually happened; they just “declared” it.